Thursday, July 1, 2010

Guide to reviewing manuscripts

Crazy-thanks to Dr. Colleen Nyberg for passing along this very helpful guide to reviewing manuscripts. Although the authors of the article are radiologists, their guidelines are fairly universal. Especially helpful is their comparison of informative and non-informative reviews. Both authors and reviewers should learn something new from this piece.


  1. Hey Hey Julienne- Could you post the reference details (title, journal, authors) for the guide- I can't access it via the link and am very interested in reading it. Thanks!

  2. Sorry about that! I reposted with what should be a live link this time.